baby shrug sleeve decision

I got a yarn delivery today (yes, on Saturday!) and amongst other goodies there was the ball I needed to finish the baby shrug that I started as a trial of the pattern.  So I was able to get out my hook and I had time to finish it, but I stopped because I’m not sure that I like the completed sleeve.  I’m looking for feedback- should I just go with the cap sleeve (on the right), or should I go with the completed lacey sleeve (on the left)?

what does everyone think?